Do I need everything on a standard registry checklist?

No. Most published registry checklists are 80+ items long and overcount. Realistically, ~14 items are 'must-have-before-birth' — and only about 6 of those need to be bought brand-new for safety reasons. The rest can wait, be hand-me-downs, or be skipped entirely.

What absolutely must be bought new?

Car seats (older than the manufacturer expiration date or that have been in a crash are unsafe). Crib mattresses — the AAP recommends a firm, flat, tight-fitting sleep surface with no wear, mold, or damage; buy new unless you can verify a used mattress meets all of those criteria. Bottle nipples (rubber breaks down). Cribs themselves must meet 2011+ CPSC standards; if you can verify that, secondhand is fine. Anything with motors, batteries, or fabric in contact with the baby that you can't verify is usually best bought new.

What can safely be secondhand?

Strollers, carriers, high chairs (check current recalls), bouncers, play mats, books, toys, clothing, bath gear, swaddles. Dressers, gliders, nightlights, and most "nice-to-have" items are excellent hand-me-down candidates.

When should we make the registry?

Most parents finalize the registry around weeks 20–28. That gives shower-throwers time to coordinate, and avoids the impulse-add reflex that hits in the last month. Aim for the registry to be done by week 32.

Which registry platform is best?

Babylist allows adding items from any retailer (Amazon, Target, small DTC brands, even cash funds), which is the killer feature for most parents. Amazon's registry is simpler but limited to Amazon SKUs. Target and Walmart registries each include a welcome box and completion discount but limit you to their own catalog.

Registry checklist

The registry checklist that doesn't oversell you.

Sorted into three buckets: must-have before birth, safety — buy new, and can wait. Cost ranges come from our gear database, so the total matches what you'll actually spend.

Open gear budget planner Jump to checklist

Budget-tier total

$1,235

All 20 items, lowest tier each.

Standard-tier total

$2,730

Mainstream brands across the board.

Must-have count

of 20 items rated must-have before birth.

The list

What to actually put on the registry

Buy new for safety

These items have safety or hygiene reasons to buy new — recall history, expiration dates, or materials that degrade.

Item	Budget	Standard	Premium
Crib	$180	$350	$700
Crib mattress	$90	$160	$280
Infant car seat	$130	$250	$450

Must-have before birth

You'll want these in the house before week 36. Secondhand is fine if verified working and within current safety guidance.

Item	Budget	Standard	Premium
Changing pad	$30	$60	$120
Stroller	$130	$350	$800
Baby monitor	$50	$150	$380
High chair	$70	$160	$320
Diaper bag	$30	$80	$200
Bottle set	$25	$60	$130
Swaddles / sleep sacks	$30	$60	$120
Thermometer	$15	$30	$70
Bedding (sheets, etc.)	$60	$120	$240

Can wait or skip

Add to the registry if guests want to give them, but you don't need them on day one. Some are nice-to-haves; some you may skip entirely.

Item	Budget	Standard	Premium
Bassinet	$100	$220	$450
Baby carrier	$50	$130	$220
Bouncer / seat	$40	$90	$180
Dresser	$120	$280	$600
Infant bathtub	$25	$50	$110
Play mat	$30	$70	$150
Nightlight	$15	$30	$70
Baby book / keepsake	$15	$30	$60

Disclosure: Some links on this page are affiliate links — if you buy through them, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. We only link to products that fit the spending plan the calculator suggests, and our rankings are never influenced by commission rates. See our methodology for how we research recommendations.

Where to make the registry

We don't recommend a specific platform — they're roughly equivalent and the choice usually comes down to where your friends/family already shop. Quick guide:

Babylist — best for cross-retailer registries. Add items from anywhere, including small DTC brands, plus cash funds for daycare, diaper subscriptions, or postpartum care.
Amazon Baby Registry — simplest interface; 15% completion discount; limited to Amazon SKUs.
Target Baby Registry — welcome box, 15% completion discount, in-store returns.
Walmart Baby Registry — welcome box, free shipping on most items.

What to do with the "can wait" list

Many parents register for everything, then realize 3 months in that half of it goes unused. A better pattern: keep the registry list tight to must-haves, and treat "can wait" items as month-3 or month-6 additions if and when you find you need them. Most baby registries allow editing post-birth.

Budget reality check

The standard-tier total above ($2,730) assumes you buy every item brand-new at mainstream brands. With registry help, hand-me-downs, and shower gifts, most parents end up paying 35–55% of this total out of pocket. Our gear budget planner models that offset.

Safety guidance is not medical or product advice. Always check current CPSC recalls and AAP safe-sleep guidance before using any product — new or secondhand. We do not recommend specific brands of car seats, cribs, or sleep products on this page.

FAQ